"God. What the hell was she thinking? This woman was so out of her league. She needed to stick with the Liz Burkes of the world—women who gave as good as they got, and never looked much beyond the landscape of their own libidos. They were her ilk. Not Julia. Julia was something else. Julia was like a stray truffle, stuck in a steaming pile of shit beneath one of those Kennett Square mushroom tents. She didn't fit." – Ann McMan, DustThat simile is courtesy of our protagonist, Evan Reed. When Dust opens, Evan agrees to vet a young senator who has ambitions of running for president. Of course, Evan falls deeply in lust with the senator's estranged wife, Julia, and of course the senator is hiding a secret that could scuttle his presidential campaign before it begins. With its swirl of conspiracies and cynicism, Dust could almost be a neo-noir. As with The Big Sleep, the motivations—even the actions—of the shadowy players are unclear; unlike that film, there's no style to compensate for the lack of substance. Also working against the novel's aspirations as a hardboiled thriller is the romance between Evan and Julia, which progresses to undying love in about forty-eight hours, without their—or, sadly, the reader's—knowing why. Caveats aside, this novel is not bad, precisely: a decent three out of five dossiers.
Showing posts with label ann mcman. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ann mcman. Show all posts
Monday, January 16, 2012
Dust by Ann McMan (2011)
Dust (2011) - Ann McMan
I not so secretly enjoyed the heck out of Jericho, Ann McMan's previous book. It's a really well-written Xena-uber that follows the blossoming relationship between a small-town doctor and the town's very first librarian. It's worth a read as well as a review, which I'll get to later.
Because I liked Jericho a lot, I had even higher expectations for Dust, especially since Jericho was McMan's debut novel. Anyway. One of the reasons that Jericho worked really well for me was character development - there was a small cast of characters, the book actually gave the would-be lovers relationships with people in the outside world (shock! gasp!) rather than marooning them on their own totally insular island of love.
Dust is structured similarly - there are family bonds, friendships, and links to vast conspiracies that the heroines must negotiate in order to escape the novel together. What made Dust different (and less enjoyable for me) was that I felt like the supporting cast in Dust was less well-fleshed out. Part of this was the fault of the suspense (sub?)plot, which was often confusing and opaque; this made it more difficult to determine what characters' motivations were, or what their motivations meant for the progress of the novel. There were too many plot lines that weren't fully articulated or even resolved - this left me questioning the purpose of some of the characters and their relationships with one another.
This was the novel's biggest failing for me. Dust wasn't a bad read - just a confusing one. If there's a sequel in the works, I suspect it would simplify matters a bit. McMan's a good writer, though, and her characters are a lot of fun. While Dust was not to my taste, I liked Jericho and would definitely read future works by her.
Rating: Three kitties out of five. Which is still a lot of kitties.
Because I liked Jericho a lot, I had even higher expectations for Dust, especially since Jericho was McMan's debut novel. Anyway. One of the reasons that Jericho worked really well for me was character development - there was a small cast of characters, the book actually gave the would-be lovers relationships with people in the outside world (shock! gasp!) rather than marooning them on their own totally insular island of love.
Dust is structured similarly - there are family bonds, friendships, and links to vast conspiracies that the heroines must negotiate in order to escape the novel together. What made Dust different (and less enjoyable for me) was that I felt like the supporting cast in Dust was less well-fleshed out. Part of this was the fault of the suspense (sub?)plot, which was often confusing and opaque; this made it more difficult to determine what characters' motivations were, or what their motivations meant for the progress of the novel. There were too many plot lines that weren't fully articulated or even resolved - this left me questioning the purpose of some of the characters and their relationships with one another.
This was the novel's biggest failing for me. Dust wasn't a bad read - just a confusing one. If there's a sequel in the works, I suspect it would simplify matters a bit. McMan's a good writer, though, and her characters are a lot of fun. While Dust was not to my taste, I liked Jericho and would definitely read future works by her.
Rating: Three kitties out of five. Which is still a lot of kitties.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)